4.10.1005    PENALTY DETERMINATION

(1) �Each violation of the Montana Pesticides Act and/or rules adopted thereunder is considered a separate offense. Each offense is subject to a separate penalty not to exceed $2,500, with the exception of farm applicators whose penalty cannot exceed $500 for the first offense.

(2) �The penalty matrixes in this rule establish the penalty for each offense that is a major violation or reoccurrence of a major violation. The values in parentheses establish the penalty for farm applicators possessing a permit. The gravity of the violation, the degree of care exercised and the degree of harm to health, environment, agricultural commodities, or livestock may decrease or increase the penalties listed below. The department shall have the option to select the most appropriate penalty and penalty value for each violation.

(3) �Where a penalty is assessed for reoccurrence of a violation within two years of the first violation, the two year period will start on the date that the preceding violation occurred. All appeals procedures and rights to contest and a final order concluding the violation must be completed for the preceding violation(s).

(4) �Penalties are assessed according to the following penalty matrix:

(a) �misuse resulting in proven exposure or proven harm to:

�

� Violation	1st Offense	2nd Offense	3rd and Subsequent Offense
Humans or human health Proven exposure Illness Chronic illness or death	� $� 500 (100) � �1,000 (200) � �2,500 (500) � �	� $1,000 ��2,500 � 2,500	� $2,500 � 2,500 � 2,500
Agricultural commodities Proven exposure Reduced yield or price Damage or residues that �� prevent marketing Destruction �	� $� 250 (50) � � � 750 (150) � �1,000 (200) � � �2,000 (400) � �	� �$� 500 � 1,500 � 2,000 � � 2,500	� $1,000 � 2,000 � 2,500 � � 2,500 �
Livestock Proven exposure Illness or residues that prevent marketing of livestock or by-products Death	� $� 250 (50) � �1,000 (200) � � � �2,500 (500) �	� �$� 500 � 2,000 � � � 2,500	� $1,000 � 2,500 � � � 2,500

�

(b) �misuse resulting in proven harm to environment:

�

Surface or ground water
Poisoning or harm to aquatic plants or animals	$ 500 (100)	$1,000	$2,500
Domestic, livestock, or irrigation purposes or other beneficial uses affected	1,000 (200)	� 2,000	� 2,500
Residues equal or exceed state or federal standards	1,000 (200)	� 2,500	� 2,500
Soil
Residues that prevent growth of plants	�� 500 (100)	�1,000	� 2,500
Structure or biota adversely affected	�� 500 (100)	�1,000	� 2,000
Animals
Illness or harm	�� 500 (100)	�1,000	� 2,500
Death	1,000 (200)	�2,000	��2,500
Residues that prevent or restrict consumption by humans	1,000 (200)	�2,000	� 2,500
Plants other than agricultural commodities
Damaged, normal the following season	� 500 (100)	�1,500	� 2,500
Damaged, abnormal the following season	1,000 (200)	�2,000	� 2,500
Destroyed	2,000 (400)	�2,500	� 2,500
Air
Contaminated at or above state or federal health standards	1,000 (200)	2,500	� 2,500

�

(c) �sale of a restricted pesticide to a person not certified or authorized to purchase restricted pesticides:

�

Sale of a restricted	$1,000 (100) �	$1,500	$2,500
pesticide to a person not	�	�	�
certified or authorized to	�	�	�
purchase restricted	�	�	�
pesticides	�	�	�

�

(d) �use or sale of an unregistered pesticide:

�

General	$1,000 (200)	$2,000	$2,500
Restricted	� 1,500 (300)	� 2,500	�� 2,500
Canceled or suspended	� 1,500 (300)	� 2,500	�� 2,500

�

�

(e) �failure to maintain any individual pesticide application and sales records:

�

General use pesticides	$250 (50)	$500	$1,000
Restricted use pesticides	500 (100)	750	� 1,500

�

(f) �use of a pesticide without having obtained the

required license or permit:

�

Commercial, government, public utility or non- commercial applicators or operators or farm applicators
General	$ 500	$1,500	$2,500
Restricted	1,000	� 2,000	���2,500
Permitted farm applicator Restricted	�� 250	� 1,000	�� 2,000

��

(g) �sale of a pesticide without having obtained the required license:

�

General	$ 500 (100)	$1,500	$2,500
Restricted	1,000 (200)	� 2,000	� 2,500

�

(h) �noncompliance with pesticide worker protection standards and labeling:

�

Misuse violations not causing proven exposure of humans, agricultural commodities or livestock; or proven harm to human health, commodities, livestock or the environment	$ 250 (50) �	$500	$1,000
Retaliation by an employer against workers or handlers	1,000 (200) �	1,500	� 2,500
Failure to provide emergency assistance	1,500 (300) �	2,000	� 2,500
Sale of a misbranded pesticide not having the required worker protection label language	�� 500 (100) �	1,500	� 2,500

�

(i) �noncompliance with pesticide ground water and environmental protection agency endangered species standards and labeling:

�

Misuse violations not causing proven exposure of humans, agricultural commodities or livestock; or proven harm to human health, commodities, livestock or the environment	$250 (50) �	$500	$1,000
	�
	�
	�	�	�

�

(j) �noncompliance with pesticide or pesticide container disposal, labeling or handling requirements and standards:

�

Misuse violations not causing proven exposure of humans, agricultural commodities or livestock; or proven harm to human health, commodities, livestock or the environment	$250 (50) �	$500	$1,000
	�	�	�
	�	�	�
	�	�	�
	�	�	�
	�	�	�
	�	�	�
Sale of a misbranded pesticide	�500 (100) �	1,500	� 2,500
	�	�

�

(k) reoccurrence of any identical violation of this chapter (Title 80, chapter 8, MCA)�within two years of the first violation excluding the major violations set forth above:

�

Type of Reoccurrence	1st Reoccurrence	2nd Reoccurrence	3rd Reoccurrence
Violations dealing with permits, licenses and/or reports	$� 500	$1,000	$2,500
Violations dealing with general use pesticides	���� 500	� 1,000	� 2,500
Violations dealing with restricted use pesticides	� 1,000	� 2,000	� 2,500
All other violations	���� 500	� 1,000	� 2,500

History: 80-8-105, MCA; IMP, 80-8-306, MCA; NEW, 1986 MAR p. 1013, Eff. 6/13/86; AMD, 1999 MAR p. 404, Eff. 3/12/99.